users online counter
Interesting
Photo: In case you thought this was about some dusty vegetable stand in the Casbah: a Spinneys Lebanon hypermarket [Image Source]
Can salad vegetables tell us something about the Arab/Israel conflict?

A minor report in today’s edition of the Lebanese newspaper, The Daily Star, deals with grocery store items and the Middle East conflict. Though it centers on nothing more substantial than packaged peppers, it might actually say something significant about how things are in this part of the world.


Israeli produce discovered in south Lebanon shop | January 01, 2013 11:36 AMBy Mohammed Zaaatari | The Daily Star |  SIDON, Lebanon | A Lebanese shopper discovered several food items made in Israel in one of Lebanon’s largest retailers Tuesday. While shopping at Spinneys in the coastal city of Sidon, a man, who preferred to remain anonymous, discovered a bag of three kinds of peppers made in Israel. He immediately contacted local authorities who in turn contacted the Lebanese Army. Members of military intelligence and police arrived to Spinneys to discover 13 similar bags that have the word “Israel” printed on the sale tag. Police also noticed that the international bar code for the items was scratched with a blue pen and a new code was handwritten on the bag.  The case was then referred to the military judiciary for investigation into how the products made it through the customs department at the port or the airport. Spinneys had a similar incident almost ten years ago when shoppers discovered mugs made in Israel being sold at the retailer.
The Lebanese newspaper report has this market-fresh cellphone snapshot of the alleged peppersCredit: Daily Star/Mohammed ZaatariWikipedia says Spinneys is a high-end supermarket chain in the Middle East which begun as railway provision merchants, and expanded to a grocery firm importing British Empire goods. [Today it’s] a premium supermarket retailer in the Middle East, and operates hypermarkets and supermarkets in one store in Qatar, seven stores in Lebanon, three stores in Egypt, one in Jordan and through franchise agreements, 29 Spinneys stores in the UAE… The largest shareholder and manager of the brand is the Dubai-based private equity firm Abraaj Capital.It would be nice to laugh, or even just to smile knowingly, about the gravity hinted at in this news item. But let’s dwell briefly, before getting too amused, about how the presence of these packaged peppers required the forensic interventions of (a) the Lebanese army, (b) its military intelligence, (c) the Lebanese national police and (d) the military judiciary.(If you’re wondering why Hezbollah, which actually runs Lebanon for all practical purposes, appears to be out of this particular loop, they’re not. But you need to consult a different report; see “Spinneys: Rooted in Lebanese Corruption” from September 2012.)Anyone who shops in European supermarkets knows that quality peppers increasingly means Israeli peppers. An angry “boycott Israeli goods” website which we will not quote here (why give them the attention or the traffic?) resentfully sings the praises of Israeli peppers and their success in penetrating discerning markets. Such is life. Israeli agriculture does a really good job of producing winning fruits and vegetables. But before checking for leaks in the border fence, it would not be surprising to learn that the peppers that infiltrated Spinneys originated with a European wholesaler.But more seriously, think about what this tells us about Lebanon and the Arab world, and about the ongoing conflict. How good are the chances for a better understanding on both sides of the dispute when the presence of one word on a printed label, whether accurately placed there or not, triggers the big-time involvement of the military, the police and the judiciary? And that’s just on the day of the “discovery”. What might be coming next. Is the Lebanese government going to fall? Will a minister resign? Will Lebanon retaliate and if so, what form will that take? And why is this not already in front of the UN Security Council or the World Health Organization?A friendly colleague shared this comment with us a short time ago:This is the problem with the “If only Israel would…” crowd. If Israel was merely involved in a political dispute with the Arab/Muslim world, there would have been peace in the Middle East decades ago. But when a simple act of commerce is treated as treason, or at least a criminal enterprise, you’re not dealing with something political given to easy solutions. You’re dealing with something pathological which needs to be changed or at least addressed before you can have peace. Of course that makes peacemaking much more challenging. Blaming Israel is a lot easier, rather than acknowledging the real problem.

Photo: In case you thought this was about some dusty vegetable stand in the Casbah: a Spinneys Lebanon hypermarket [Image Source]

Can salad vegetables tell us something about the Arab/Israel conflict?

A minor report in today’s edition of the Lebanese newspaper, The Daily Star, deals with grocery store items and the Middle East conflict. Though it centers on nothing more substantial than packaged peppers, it might actually say something significant about how things are in this part of the world.
Israeli produce discovered in south Lebanon shop | January 01, 2013 11:36 AM
By Mohammed Zaaatari | The Daily Star |  SIDON, Lebanon | A Lebanese shopper discovered several food items made in Israel in one of Lebanon’s largest retailers Tuesday. While shopping at Spinneys in the coastal city of Sidon, a man, who preferred to remain anonymous, discovered a bag of three kinds of peppers made in Israel. He immediately contacted local authorities who in turn contacted the Lebanese Army. Members of military intelligence and police arrived to Spinneys to discover 13 similar bags that have the word “Israel” printed on the sale tag. Police also noticed that the international bar code for the items was scratched with a blue pen and a new code was handwritten on the bag.  The case was then referred to the military judiciary for investigation into how the products made it through the customs department at the port or the airport. Spinneys had a similar incident almost ten years ago when shoppers discovered mugs made in Israel being sold at the retailer.
The Lebanese newspaper report 
has this market-fresh cellphone 
snapshot of the alleged peppers
Credit: Daily Star/
Mohammed Zaatari

Wikipedia
 says Spinneys is a high-end supermarket chain in the Middle East which begun as railway provision merchants, and expanded to a grocery firm importing British Empire goods. [Today it’s] a premium supermarket retailer in the Middle East, and operates hypermarkets and supermarkets in one store in Qatar, seven stores in Lebanon, three stores in Egypt, one in Jordan and through franchise agreements, 29 Spinneys stores in the UAE… The largest shareholder and manager of the brand is the Dubai-based private equity firm Abraaj Capital.
It would be nice to laugh, or even just to smile knowingly, about the gravity hinted at in this news item. But let’s dwell briefly, before getting too amused, about how the presence of these packaged peppers required the forensic interventions of (a) the Lebanese army, (b) its military intelligence, (c) the Lebanese national police and (d) the military judiciary.

(If you’re wondering why Hezbollah, which actually runs Lebanon for all practical purposes, appears to be out of this particular loop, they’re not. But you need to consult a different report; see “Spinneys: Rooted in Lebanese Corruption” from September 2012.)

Anyone who shops in European supermarkets knows that quality peppers increasingly means Israeli peppers. An angry “boycott Israeli goods” website which we will not quote here (why give them the attention or the traffic?) resentfully sings the praises of Israeli peppers and their success in penetrating discerning markets. Such is life. Israeli agriculture does a really good job of producing winning fruits and vegetables. But before checking for leaks in the border fence, it would not be surprising to learn that the peppers that infiltrated Spinneys originated with a European wholesaler.

But more seriously, think about what this tells us about Lebanon and the Arab world, and about the ongoing conflict. How good are the chances for a better understanding on both sides of the dispute when the presence of one word on a printed label, whether accurately placed there or not, triggers the big-time involvement of the military, the police and the judiciary? And that’s just on the day of the “discovery”. What might be coming next. Is the Lebanese government going to fall? Will a minister resign? Will Lebanon retaliate and if so, what form will that take? And why is this not already in front of the UN Security Council or the World Health Organization?

A friendly colleague shared this comment with us a short time ago:
This is the problem with the “If only Israel would…” crowd. If Israel was merely involved in a political dispute with the Arab/Muslim world, there would have been peace in the Middle East decades ago. But when a simple act of commerce is treated as treason, or at least a criminal enterprise, you’re not dealing with something political given to easy solutions. You’re dealing with something pathological which needs to be changed or at least addressed before you can have peace. Of course that makes peacemaking much more challenging. Blaming Israel is a lot easier, rather than acknowledging the real problem.
UAE’s stateless acquire foreign passports. By Camilla Hall and Michael Peel
A stateless Arab, known as Bidoons. ©AFPAhmed may hold a passport for the Comoros Islands but he has never been to the east African archipelago and he would have trouble finding it on a map.

Yet, denied citizenship in his United Arab Emirates birthplace, he has become one of a number of stateless people in the oil-rich country who have acquired the nationality of a group of islands with which they have no ties. His goal: to secure the official identity he needs to travel and access basic services.

“We’re seeing much more of a security state in the Gulf,” says Kristian Ulrichsen, a Gulf expert at the London School of Economics. “Regimes feel more threatened and more concerned over who is in and who is out.”

Ahmed’s unusual tale holds a mirror to the legal and social troubles that face hundreds of thousands of stateless people, known as “bidoun”, across the Gulf, which have intensified with the uprisings across the Arab world. In Kuwait, some members of the 105,000-strong bidoun population have been arrested after street protests against the government’s reluctance to offer citizenship. In the UAE, rights activists have raised concerns over what they say is the possible deportation of a bidoun political campaigner detained last month.“Either I should bury myself and die or try to survive,” Ahmed says of the decision.

The term bidoun – “without” in Arabic – refers to long-time residents whose ancestors failed to apply for formal identity papers as the discovery of oil prompted the rapid transformation of the region from a Bedouin culture to an urban economy. Without these basic documents, they have since struggled without secure healthcare, education and jobs.

While the public demonstrations of Kuwait’s bidoun that began early last year have not been repeated in other countries, stateless people are found across the Gulf. The UN estimates that Saudi Arabia is home to 70,000 of them. Between 30,000 and 100,000 more are estimated to live in the UAE.

Uprisings across the Arab world have widened the schism between the bidoun and the region’s wealthy nationals. Increased spending by Gulf states on salaries and subsidies to quell the possibility of unrest – with pay rises of up to 120 per cent last year for some government workers – have made it increasingly attractive to be a citizen.

“As the value of having Gulf citizenship has increased, the disparity between the haves and the have-nots has gone up,” Mr Ulrichsen says.

The Arab revolts have also made the bidoun more vulnerable to security-conscious governments suspicious of perceived outsiders and alleged enemies within. Kuwaiti authorities, for example, say the bidoun have been infiltrated by imposters from countries such as Iraq and Syria, who destroy their passports so they can ultimately claim nationality.

In the UAE, the bidoun’s difficulties have surfaced in the curious case of the Comoros passports. At least a thousand stateless residents have taken the documents, says Zoubert A Soufiane Al Ahdal, Comoros ambassador to the UAE.

Bidoun in the UAE say the Comoros documents make it easier for them to meet tougher official identity requirements for securing papers such as vehicle renewals – and perhaps even eventually, somewhat paradoxically, a UAE passport.

It is unclear who is paying for the passports: two of four bidoun interviewed by the Financial Times said they thought the UAE government had paid for theirs. Ambassador Ahdal denied this, while the UAE authorities declined to comment.

While the Comoros passports seem on one level to offer a little respite for the bidoun and a convenient partial solution for the UAE government, some rights activists say moves by stateless people to secure foreign nationality have a darker dimension that has grown in significance since the Arab uprisings began.

Disturbed by small murmurings of political dissent and in particular by the activities of suspected Islamists, the UAE authorities have begun using nationality as a legal tool as Qatar did in 2005, when it revoked the citizenship of as many as 6,000 people.

The UAE government last year revoked the citizenship of seven members of al-Islah, an Islamist organisation, turning them into bidoun and arresting many of them later for refusing to sign undertakings that they would take on a new passport.

“Wherever citizenship is exclusive it can be used as a weapon,” says Michael Stephens, Gulf expert at the Royal United Services Institute in Doha.

In another UAE case, Human Rights Watch said last month that Ahmed Abd al-Khaleq, a detailed UAE-born bidoun campaigner, now fears deportation on the basis of his recently acquired Comorian nationality. Mr Abd al-Khaleq was one of five pro-democracy activists imprisoned last year for insulting the UAE’s leaders and later pardoned.

The UAE authorities declined to comment on Mr Abd al-Khaleq’s case. Officials have previously said thousands of other bidoun have been given UAE nationality, after a 2006 pledge by Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan, the president, to resolve the problem once and for all.

That’s a penalty kick you don’t see every day!

With the exception of Lebanon and Iraq, there has never been a genuinely free election in any of the other twenty-two Arab League countries. After one attempt at an election in the UAE in 2006 attracted low voter turnout, a prominent member of the government remarked, ‘This is particularly disappointing given that all of the candidates and participants were from very good families, and were all personally approved by the UAE’s rulers.’
Christopher M. Davidson, Dubai: The Vulnerability of Success (New York: Columbia University Press, 2008), p. 166.
free counters